• קורסים לדיבור מול קהל
  • אירועים והרצאות
  • סדנאות נאום מקוונות
    סדנה: איך לברך לחג ואירוע
    guyariv

    סדנה: איך לברך לחג ואירוע

    guyariv
    23
    students
    ₪199.00 ₪99.00
  • אודות
    • אודות בית הספר לדיבור מול קהל
    • מפה והוראות הגעה
    • בלוג
  • צרו-קשר
  • he_ILHE
  • ENEN
    • RegisterLogin
    • Cart

      0
      • GET STARTED
    גיא יריב - בית הספר לדיבור מול קהל
    • קורסים לדיבור מול קהל
    • אירועים והרצאות
    • סדנאות נאום מקוונות
      סדנה: איך לברך לחג ואירוע
      guyariv

      סדנה: איך לברך לחג ואירוע

      guyariv
      23
      students
      ₪199.00 ₪99.00
    • אודות
      • אודות בית הספר לדיבור מול קהל
      • מפה והוראות הגעה
      • בלוג
    • צרו-קשר
    • he_ILHE
    • ENEN
    • RegisterLogin
    • Cart

      0
      • GET STARTED

      english

      Rebuttal and contradictions

      • Date יולי 23, 2009
      • Comments 0 comment

      עמוד זה הינו תרגום של מאמר מתוך הקורס המקוון לדיבור מול קהל, העוסק בסתירת טיעונים

      In the previous lesson we learned how to construct arguments, and in particular, we learned that  a good argument should include four parts:

      1. A claim – the proposition which the argument is trying to prove
      2. Logic – The theoretical reasons that back the main claim
      3. Evidents – Facts that support the claim and the logic, and connect them to actual reality
      4. Leverage – An optional part, that show how the proven argument furthers the case of the speech

      In this lesson we shall learn how to refute and dis-prove an argument, and we will learn that we can refute each of the four parts of the arguments.

      Rebuttting the main claim (A CounterArgument)

      This method counters the argument without disproving it.  It is a ‘yes, but’ argument saying, in effect, ‘what you say may be true, BUT i have a stronger argument against it’. Therefore, this rebuttal is not  actually negative content that shows your oponent to be mitaken, but rather a positive content arguing yourcase.

      For example, we can say “it might be true that watching violent movies promotes violence, but violent films are still free speech protected under  the law”. In this case the counter argument does not clash with the original, it merely shows an opposing claim.

      Rebutting the Logical Explanation

      Refuting logic is quite often the hardest form of rebuttal, because it often involves abstract reasoning, and requires analytical skill that is difficult tom master on-stage.  There are two main ways of challenging the logic of an oponent- the harder way is to find holes in their logic such as an internal contradiction or a logical fallacy (for example “It is a mistake that watching violent films make you violent, rather, people who are violent enjoy watching violent films”).

      An easier way of rebutting the logic of an oponent is offering an alternative explanation to his logic and fats (for example “if watching violence on television was indeed promoting violence, we should have seen more of it in people watching the news”).

      Rebutting Facts and Evidence

      Finding fault in the facts is easier than finding faults in logic, and factual rebuttal is therefore easier and more natural to most people.  It can be done in two ways – countering the facts with opposing facts, or questioning the source of the facts.

      • Introducing opposing facts – this is the simplest and most straighforward way of contradicting an oponent. You simply bring your own facts that show that their facts are wrong or misleading.  The advantage of this method is that it is simple to do, but the downside is that you actaully have to have opposing facts.
        For Example – “during the 1990’s America has seen a steady decline in street violence even as the television broadcasted increasing amounts of violence”
      • Questioning the source of the facts – this method is very useful as it does not require any knowledge from your part.  The idea is that whatever facts your oponent brings must have a source, and that source is always fallible – it is either outdated, biased, its methodology or sample is wrong. or it may have been misquoted.

      Rebutting the leverage

      This rebuttal is not on the argument itself, but on whatever conclusions are drawn from it. The essence of this rebuttal is ‘you exaggarage’. It is not an attack on your openent’s argument itself, but on the conclusions your oponent.  Doing that, your oponent may base an unrealistic plan on an otherwise sound logic.

      for example “even if we agreed that there’s damage in violent films, it is outrageous to propose creating a censorship board. what are we, china?”

      dishonorable rebuttals

      1. changing the subject (spin)
        You can sometimes circumvent a powerful argument by changing the subject, especially if you steer the discussion towards a more emotional issue. for example “it is a futile waste of time to discuss TV violence when our children commit real violence against arab children”
      2. Personal attaces (‘Ad Hominem’)
        Instead of attacking the arguments, it is possible to attack the person making them. For Example “How can you, Guy Yariv, purport to oppose violence when your website publishes an article supporting corporal punishment in schools?’
      3. Physical Interruption
        It is always effective to prevent a good argument being made by disrupting the speaker with loud noises or constant questions and interruptions

      הירשם לקורס דיבור מול קהל (עברית או אנגלית)

       

       sdfs

      • Share:
      author avatar
      guyariv

      Previous post

      arguments and argumentation
      יולי 23, 2009

      Next post

      חשיבות הכנסת הרפואה המשלימה לתוכנית הלימודים האקדמית
      יולי 25, 2009

      You may also like

      Corporate courses, workshops & lectures
      17 מאי, 2020

      Get your message across. An organization is a conversation machine.  Bosses run meetings, Sales people present to clients, HR recruits and trains, etc.  And if your messages don’t come across as they should you lose time, or money, or goodwill. …

      Community activities and events
      17 מאי, 2020

      Our alumni Community After 13 years and 280 courses, we have a thriving community of 3,600 students and graduates engaged in our public speaking community. Our alumni tutor new students, volunteer for lectures in needing communities, participate in our Debate-club …

      Structure and overcoming Stage fright
      5 ספטמבר, 2013

      In the previous article we saw that a disogranized speech leads to increased stage fright because (among aothers) it makes black-outs more likely.  In this article we look at 2 practical solutions to the problem. The structure solution Paradoxically, the …

      Leave A Reply

      האימייל לא יוצג באתר. שדות החובה מסומנים *

      קטגוריות

      • about
        • career
        • press
        • research
        • team
      • advanced
      • articles
      • assertive
        • אימון-אישי
      • blog
      • business
      • consulting
      • contact-us
      • content
      • course
        • reading-audience
      • debate
        • academy
        • bio-ethics
        • censor
        • coffee
        • environment
        • law
        • religion
        • sex
        • transplants
        • universities
        • welfare
        • דיבייט התחממות גלובלית
      • english
      • feminism
      • guides
      • interpersonal
      • manual
      • manuel
      • members
      • motions
      • office
      • presentations
      • press
      • promotion
      • rhetorics
        • body-language
        • classic
        • fallacies
        • holiday
        • propoganda
      • sales
      • social-network
      • social-networking
      • social-phobia
      • soldiers
      • speech
      • speech-anxiety
      • speeches
      • stagefright
        • behavioral
        • blackout
        • dynamic-therapy
        • vice-versa
      • stagefright4
      • teachers
      • Uncategorized
      • updates
      • voice
      • קמפיין

      Latest Courses

      סדנה: איך לברך לחג ואירוע

      סדנה: איך לברך לחג ואירוע

      ₪199.00 ₪99.00
      סדנה מקוונת לשיווק עצמי

      סדנה מקוונת לשיווק עצמי

      ₪99.00
      סדנת חונכים לדיבור מול קהל – מתחילים

      סדנת חונכים לדיבור מול קהל – מתחילים

      Free

      Become an Instructor

      Join our community of students around the world and sell your courses.

      Learn More

      contact us so we can find a solution for you

      contact us so we can find a solution for you
      CONTACT
      •   +972-506-488-069
      •   1-800-100-192
      •  127, Byialik St.
        Diamond Exchange District
        Ramat-Gan, Israel
      COMPANY
      • debate
      • articles
      • content
      • rhetorics
      • stagefright
      • updates
      USEFUL LINKS
      • Courses
      • Events
      • Gallery
      • התחייבות לשביעות רצון ומדיניות החזרים וביטולים
      SUPPORT
      • Documentation
      • Forums
      • Language Packs
      • Release Status
      MOBILE

      Click and Get started in seconds

       

      • debate
      • articles
      • content
      • rhetorics
      • stagefright
      • updates
      Facebook-f Twitter Google-plus-g Linkedin-in

      כל הזכויות שמורות גיא יריב 2022 All rights reserved to Guy Yariv

      • Privacy
      • Terms
      • Sitemap
      • Purchase

      Login with your site account

      Lost your password?

      Not a member yet? Register now

      Register a new account

      18 − twelve =

      Are you a member? Login now

      • →
      • צור קשר

        נשמח לשמוע ממך!